
A spice quote of $2.00 per pound FOB and a quote of $2.30 per pound delivered from a U.S. warehouse are not $0.30 apart. They describe two different purchases: the first prices product loaded on a vessel overseas, the second prices product at your dock, already cleared. Before comparing them, both have to be converted to the same basis, which is the total cost per usable pound at your facility.
Incoterms® 2020, published by the International Chamber of Commerce, define where costs and risk pass from seller to buyer. They do not set the price, the specification or who handles FDA requirements, so each of those still needs to be agreed in the contract.
What each term includes, and what it leaves to you
| FOB | CIF | DDP | U.S. importer, delivered | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ocean freight paid by seller | No | Yes | Yes | Included in price |
| Insurance | Buyer arranges | Seller buys minimum cover | Not required, seller carries transit risk | Included in price |
| Risk passes to buyer | On board at origin port | On board at origin port | At named delivery place | At delivery |
| U.S. clearance and duties | Buyer | Buyer | Seller | Already handled by supplier |
| What you still need to confirm | Every cost after loading | Insurance coverage, U.S. charges | FDA responsibilities, unloading, excluded fees | Ex-warehouse or delivered, stock status |
FOB is the most common basis for overseas spice quotes and the one that leaves the most cost off the page. Risk passes to you once the goods are loaded at the origin port, so a container damaged or delayed at sea is your claim to manage. For containerized cargo handed to a carrier at a terminal before loading, the ICC recommends FCA instead, because the seller loses control of the container before it is on board.
CIF looks more complete because the seller pays freight to a U.S. port, but risk still passes at origin, exactly as under FOB. The seller only has to buy minimum insurance under Institute Cargo Clauses (C), which exclude many common causes of loss. Review the policy or buy your own coverage.
DDP moves the most work to the seller, including U.S. customs clearance and duties. It does not automatically move FDA responsibility. Under the Foreign Supplier Verification Program rule, the FSVP importer is the U.S. owner or consignee of the food at entry, which in a DDP purchase is often the buyer. Confirm in writing who files Prior Notice and who maintains FSVP records before agreeing to DDP terms.
The U.S. charges an FOB price leaves out
- Ocean freight and cargo insurance for the route, container size and season.
- Importer Security Filing (ISF or “10+2”): required for ocean shipments at least 24 hours before cargo is loaded at origin. Late or missing filings can lead to CBP penalties.
- Duties and tariffs: set by HTS classification, country of origin and entry date. Many spices carry a free or low general duty rate, but additional tariff measures have changed repeatedly since 2025, so check the rate for your actual entry date. Our article on the Supreme Court tariff ruling covers the most recent changes.
- Merchandise Processing Fee (MPF): 0.3464% of the entered value on formal entries, with a minimum and maximum per entry that CBP adjusts each fiscal year.
- Harbor Maintenance Fee (HMF): 0.125% of the cargo value for shipments arriving by vessel.
- Broker, bond and port charges: entry fees, customs bond, terminal handling, and storage, demurrage or detention if the container is not picked up or returned on time.
- Drayage from the port to your warehouse or plant.
- FDA review and testing: FDA can examine, sample or hold a shipment, and many buyers test incoming lots before release. Both add cost and days.
One detail changes the math on CIF offers. U.S. duties are assessed on transaction value, which generally excludes international freight and insurance when they are shown separately. Ask the seller to itemize freight and insurance on the commercial invoice so you do not pay duty on shipping costs.
A worked example: from FOB price to cost per usable pound
The figures below are illustrative, not market quotes. They show how the costs add up for one 20-foot container of a whole spice bought at $2.00 per pound FOB.
| Cost line | Amount |
|---|---|
| Product: 30,000 lb at $2.00/lb FOB | $60,000 |
| Ocean freight and insurance | $3,500 |
| Duties (0% general rate, no additional tariffs assumed) | $0 |
| MPF (0.3464% of $60,000) | $208 |
| HMF (0.125% of $60,000) | $75 |
| Broker, ISF and bond | $400 |
| Port charges and drayage | $1,200 |
| Incoming lot testing | $600 |
| Cost of capital (10 weeks at 8% a year on $60,000) | $923 |
| Total | $66,906 |
| Usable pounds after 0.5% sampling and handling loss | 29,850 lb |
| Landed cost per usable pound | $2.24 |
In this example, the real cost is 12% above the FOB price before any tariff applies. Each additional 10% duty on the $60,000 entered value would add $6,000, or about $0.20 per usable pound. The $2.24 figure, not the original $2.00, is what should be compared against a delivered domestic quote.
Transit time is also a cash cost
Direct imports usually require payment before the product can be used, often a deposit at order and the balance against shipping documents. From that point until the lot clears testing and reaches production, the cash is committed but the ingredient is not available. If a lot is held or delayed, buyers often have to carry more safety stock or make a spot purchase at a higher price, which never appears on the original quote.
Questions to ask before comparing quotes
For an overseas exporter:
- Which Incoterm, which version and which named port or place?
- Are freight and insurance itemized on the commercial invoice?
- What insurance coverage is included, and under which clauses?
- When is each payment due?
- Who files the ISF and Prior Notice, and who is the FSVP importer?
For a U.S. supplier:
- Is the price ex-warehouse or delivered to your facility?
- Is the product in U.S. inventory now, and what is the lead time if not?
- Which documents come with each lot (COA, country of origin, allergen statement)?
- Have duties already been paid, and could a tariff change affect the price before delivery?
Which option costs less
Direct importing can lower cost for buyers with steady volume, an established customs broker and an FSVP program already in place. For smaller or irregular volumes, the administrative work and the cash tied up in transit often erase the gap in unit price. In both cases, the right comparison is total delivered cost per usable pound for the same specification and delivery date. To compare a quote from Majestic Spice against an import offer, contact our team with the product, specification, volume and delivery location.